Hardie Board vs. Stucco: Which Should I Choose for Siding?

Hardie Board vs. Stucco: Which Should I Choose for Siding?

When it comes to house siding, you have a handful of materials to choose from. You may opt for brick, vinyl, wood, stone veneer, and aluminum. But on a more specific note, you have the option to choose between a Hardie board and stucco. The question is: which siding material should you pick?

Here at Cobex Construction Group, we’re specialized in siding services, apart from roofing, windows, painting, patio covers, and HVAC services. We offer different siding solutions based on your home needs which come with a 30-year warranty. Whether you choose Hardie board or stucco, this siding contractor in Sacramento has your back!

In this article, we’ll discuss the differences between a Hardie board and stucco to help you make informed decisions about your house siding. Keep reading to see which option to choose.

Hardie board vs. Stucco

Let’s look first at the major difference between the Hardie board and stucco:

  • Hardie board: It was James Hardie who introduced fiber cement products in the 1980s. He paved the way for the production, proliferation, and installation of this siding material, now known as the Hardie board. 

For the uninitiated, this fiber cement is mixed with about 10% wood fiber with fly ash or silica sand. Hardie board comes in various forms for house exterior sidings, such as lap siding, longboards, panels, and shingles.

  • Stucco: This siding material has been used in the world of construction for a long time. It has evolved from the standard white-washed model to a wide range of textures and colors. This material is a mixture of Portland cement, sand, and lime. During the actual installation, the powder product is mixed with water to create a paste, which is then applied over lath or mesh. Similar to Hardie board, stucco is also ideal for house exterior siding.

What option to choose: Hardie board or stucco?

Keep in mind that both Hardie board and stucco materials are perfect for home siding. However, your decision all boils down to your needs, personal preferences, and budget. Here are some attributes you may want to consider:

Hardie board

  • It is known for its strength, durability, and longevity.
  • It is notable for its drying flexibility.
  • It is resilient to temperature changes and wet climates.
  • It requires minimal upkeep but can last for years.
  • It comes in various colors and different texture options.
  • It can be painted or repainted.

Stucco

  • It is known for its long lifespan—around 50 to 80 years.
  • It creates a strong surface with fire-retardant properties. However, it requires regular maintenance since it is prone to damage and cracking.
  • It is more affordable than the Hardie board.
  • Painting this material can be laborious.

Based on the qualities and attributes mentioned above, you must factor in your home location, house type, home design, and what you want to achieve. These can help you decide which material to choose.

Conclusion

At this point, you now have a robust understanding of the differences between the Hardie board and stucco as materials for house siding. To that end, be sure to consider all the valuable information discussed above. Most importantly, work with a highly reputable home contractor who can handle your house siding! 

The Cobex Construction Group is a general contractor in Sacramento, specializing in exterior trades—windows, siding, painting, and roof repair services. If you’re looking to install Hardie board or stucco for your house siding, connect with us today to get a free quote!

Leave a Reply